A few weeks back, we asked our readers to grade the 2026 MLB local TV broadcasters. They anointed the San Diego Padres TV broadcasters as the best in the business for the second straight year.
Baseball is a sport appreciated in many ways. And while the TV booths and voices get much of the glory, we wanted to make sure we put the spotlight on the local radio broadcast as well. The original way to enjoy a Major League Baseball game from the comfort of your home, the radio call remains synonymous with baseball’s romantic nostalgia, whether you’re listening at home, in the car, on the beach, or anywhere else.
We asked Awful Announcing readers to evaluate every local radio broadcast crew for all 30 MLB teams, assign each a grade from A to F, and share comments. The results, based on more than 10,000 individual grades, are below.
It’s an interesting year for local radio rankings as it includes several longtime and iconic voices in their final season on the call (Mets’ Howie Rose, Mariners’ Rick Rizzs). It’ll be interesting to see not just where their broadcasts landed but where they rank next year with their replacements.
This is the second year we’re doing these rankings. You can find the 2025 version here for reference. And if there’s any consolation to those near the bottom of the rankings, it’s that even then, most of the grades don’t go below the A/B/C threshold.
The rankings are listed below, from No. 30 to No. 1. Each entry lists the team, its primary play-by-play announcer, primary analyst(s), notable substitutes, and game reporters (If we forgot someone, please let us know).
MLB Network Radio is currently playing the #Rockies game from August 1 as part of their MLB Classic Game series.
Colorado completed an improbable 17-16 win – vis walkoff homer – against Pittsburgh after surrendering nine runs in the first innings. pic.twitter.com/GK9icVnftV
— Patrick Lyons (@PatrickDLyons) November 23, 2025
30. Colorado Rockies (Jack Corrigan, Jeff Dooley, Zach Goodman): 1.61
Most common grade: C (39.7% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 57.9%
2025 Ranking: 29th
Bringing up the rear, the Rockies’ radio feed appears to run into criticism when it comes to engaging listeners. Veteran radio voice Jack Corrigan was acknowledged by some as a “pro’s pro” and “as good as ever” with a classic home run call (“It’s touch ‘em all time!”), but critics worry his overall style is “dull” and “outdated.” The addition of first-year voice Zach Goodman drew mixed reviews from graders, with some saying he’s “got some skills that should grow with the team’s young core,” while others labeled him a “nepo hire” and felt his play-by-play was “not major league quality.” Jeff Dooley got some love, with one grader adding, “the broadcast jumps significantly” when he’s on.
“This group deserves a better team’s games to call,” said one grader.
Kyle Stowers WALKS IT OFF and the @Marlins WIN!
: @Jack_McMullen11pic.twitter.com/sIyY9fhEMN
— Marlins Radio Network (@MarlinsRadio) March 28, 2025
29. Miami Marlins (Jack McMullen, Rod Allen, Jeff Nelson, Gaby Sánchez, Kelly Saco, Craig Minervini, AJ Ramos): 1.79
Most common grade: C (42.9% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 66.9%
2025 Ranking: 30th
The good news for the Marlins crew is that they’re out of the basement. The bad news is that it’s not by much. Young play-by-play announcer Jack McMullen earned individual praise as a “keeper” and a “big, big improvement,” thanks to strong preparation and a great radio voice. Supporting analysts like Kelly Saco and Gaby Sánchez also receive positive mentions. However, the broadcast is dragged down by an “overcrowded” booth and a perceived “lack of experience all around.” Critical graders complain about long, off-topic conversations—such as “talking about the difference between 2% and whole milk for three minutes” during live action. “Too many cooks in the kitchen,” opined one grader.
“How refreshing, a [radio] team that doesn’t make it all about themselves, doesn’t speak to hear the sound of their own voices,” added one fan. “And actually is adept at describing the action and acting as the eyes of the listener.”
28. Los Angeles Angels (Terry Smith, Mark Langston, Wayne Hagin, Bobby Grich): 1.81
Most common grade: C (38.2% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 64.9%
2025 Ranking: 24th
A bit of a dip this season for the Angels’ radio broadcast. Even so, Terry Smith and Mark Langston were credited with offering “clear, accurate game descriptions” with “pleasing” voices that “avoid irritating redundant banter.” However, the broadcast was heavily penalized due to organizational decisions by the Angels, most notably the team’s controversial policy of not sending radio announcers on the road. Listeners express intense frustration with remote broadcasts, noting that play-by-play can be “seemingly behind the play” while navigating “excessive commercial reads.” Wayne Hagin’s commentary also draws sharp criticism. As one voter bluntly sums it up: “Quality voices, but cheap owner policies ruin the broadcast.”
“It’s hard to be good when your cheap owner won’t even pay to have you broadcast games on the road,” said one grader.
“It is GONE. IT’S GONE. IT’S GONE. IT’S GONE. JOSÉ ALTUVE GIVES THE ASTROS A 5-4 LEAD HOW DO YOU LIKE THAT?”
Robert Ford calls José Altuve’s game-winning home run in Game 5 of the ALCS.pic.twitter.com/zzaoYhlIEB
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) October 21, 2023
27. Houston Astros (Robert Ford, Steve Sparks, Michael Coffin): 1.91
Most common grade: C (43.9% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 70%
2025 Ranking: 25th
Play-by-play voice Robert Ford earns widespread respect as a “solid professional” who is “never too high, never too low” on the call. His “detailed,” “methodical” approach keeps listeners engaged, and his calls during Houston’s championship runs remain “fond memories” for fans. However, partner Steve Sparks draws mixed reactions, with critics claiming his humor can feel “forced” and his color analysis “repetitive.” Other graders dismissed the broadcast as lacking excitement, noting that “nothing stands out and that’s the problem.” Still, for fans seeking a calm, reliable call, Ford has cemented himself as a voice worth listening to.
“Robert Ford is a top-notch play-by-play man and pays attention to so much in the game,” said one fan. “Has become a fixture in Houston.”
JOE BLOCK AND NEIL WALKER JUST SPOKE THIS ONEIL CRUZ HOME RUN INTO EXISTENCE!!!
Walker: “Well you know Joe, the Pirates haven’t hit a HR in this series, wink wink”
Block: “And Cruz is about due…”
108.1 MPH exit velocity, 369 feet, HR in 29/30 ballparks pic.twitter.com/NqyBJpC0jF
— Platinum Key (@PlatinumKey13) April 13, 2024
26. Pittsburgh Pirates (Joe Block, John Wehner, Greg Brown, Bob Walk, Matt Capps, Neil Walker, Kevin Young): 1.99
Most common grade: C (39.9% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 72.6%
2025 Ranking: 26th
The Pirates’ broadcast has almost exactly the same average grade and ranking as last year. Something to be said for consistency, right? The dividing factor in listener appreciation appears to depend on who is calling the game. Greg Brown earned lots of praise for his “authentic enthusiasm,” while color analysts Bob Walk and John Wehner provide an “old-school, no-nonsense” player perspective. Conversely, Joe Block receives heavy criticism from respondents who find his mechanics inconsistent, with one voter remarking that he “brings the entire group down.” Younger analysts Matt Capps and Neil Walker were highlighted as promising additions. Ultimately, while fans enjoy Brown and Walk, Block’s mixed reviews pull down the overall grade.
“Good play-by-play announcers, and it’s nice to see Capps & Walker developing,” said one grader.
Appreciation tweet for these gentleman. Cory Provus has been great on TV. Really enjoy listening to him. Kris Atteberry is fantastic on the radio, I’ve always felt that & I’m happy he has the gig full time. Dan Gladden is underrated. Adds a different perspective & voice which is… pic.twitter.com/gBinn5jvyF
— Jeff (@MNTwinsZealot) May 12, 2024
25. Minnesota Twins (Kris Atteberry, Dan Gladden, Sean Aronson, Paul Molitor, Glen Perkins): 2.01
Most common grade: C (43.5% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 75.3%
2025 Ranking: 23rd
Kris Atteberry continues to impress some listeners after replacing Cory Provus, who moved to television, with his “deep statistical knowledge” and “preparation.” However, Atteberry’s polarizing vocal style generates significant pushback, with detractors complaining he “tries too hard to sound smart” or drowns out game action with “non-stop talking” about numbers. Former Twins outfielder Dan Gladden gets a lot of praise as well, as “one of the best radio analysts in the majors,” though his play-by-play fill-in work can be a little “rough.” A real split consensus in the comments.
“Glen Perkins is really good too when he fills in,” added one grader.
Tommy Thrall and Chris Welsh making fun of the Cubs fan for his poor attempt at throwing back Dane Myers’ home run ball
#Reds
pic.twitter.com/zITZorwKeu— Chatterbox Sports (@CBoxSports) August 31, 2026
24. Cincinnati Reds (Tommy Thrall, Jeff Brantley, Jim Day, Chris Welsh): 2.02
Most common grade: C (39% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 72%
2025 Ranking: 19th
Another broadcast that took a slight dip in the rankings compared to last year. Play-by-play announcer Tommy Thrall is viewed as a “solid” and “dependable” voice, but color analyst Jeff Brantley (“The Cowboy”) is the undisputed star of the show. Listeners describe Brantley as “relatable, hilarious, and brashly honest,” noting that his unfiltered insights and mechanical knowledge “carry the broadcast.” Jim Day and Chris Welsh provide decent support, though Welsh’s “traditional” mindset draws occasional critiques. Some voters dismiss the booth as feeling a bit “flat” or “boring” during non-Brantley innings. However, many Reds fans consider Thrall and Brantley “a severely underrated duo” that beats watching the game on TV.
“While he eschews more modern stats, [Brantley’s] grasp of mechanics and his ability to call out players is terrific,” said one grader.
There is nothing quite like a Ken Korach walk-off call. You can feel the magic off the crack of Nick Kurtz’s bat. #Athleticspic.twitter.com/c3KnfPhQL0
— Uprooted (@uprootedoakland) June 17, 2025
23. Athletics (Ken Korach, Johnny Doskow, Chris Caray): 2.05
Most common grade: C (40.8% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 74.7%
2025 Ranking: 27th
The Athletics’ radio broadcast moved in the right direction in this year’s rankings. No small thing considering the uncertainty surrounding the franchise. Lead voice Ken Korach was celebrated as “an amazing beacon of consistency” and “one of the best out there.” Meanwhile, fans felt Johnny Doskow brings an “appealing” voice and great personal story, though critics note he can occasionally struggle to “properly convey the emotions of the moment.” Listeners sympathize with the booth calling games for a struggling team, noting that Korach’s regal delivery is often “the only thing saving a miserable season.” While some graders voice nostalgia for past announcers, they remain deeply appreciative of Korach’s “professionalism.”
As one voter puts it: “Love listening to Ken Korach despite how bad the A’s are.”
Relive the largest comeback in the Majors this season, as told through the voices of the Royals Radio Network! pic.twitter.com/dv2PqRvVa1
— Kansas City Royals (@Royals) April 27, 2026
22. Kansas City Royals (Denny Matthews, Jake Eisenberg, Ryan Lefebvre, Steve Stewart): 2.09
Most common grade: C (42.3% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 76.5%
2025 Ranking: 15th
Ford C. Frick Award-winning broadcaster Denny Matthews is continuing his “iconic” career alongside “rising star” Jake Eisenberg. Eisenberg earns glowing praise as “one of the most underrated broadcasters in the sport,” lauded for his “incredible cadence” and wise-beyond-his-years “picture-painting ability.” While Matthews’ “stoic, veteran voice” evokes decades of Royals history, several voters note the 83-year-old icon is understandably “past his prime.” TV crossover voice Ryan Lefebvre also adds “polished depth” when stepping in. Overall, respondents describe it as a “charming,” “underrated booth” with a bright future in Eisenberg.
“Denny still has that iconic voice that resonates with KC Royals baseball,” said one fan. “It may sound older than when I grew up listening to him, but he still has it.”
Chris Garagiola Waldschmidt Walkoff Homer Radio Call!@ChrisGaragiola#dbackspic.twitter.com/GScaJS7rWH
— maxy (@maxy637) August 8, 2026
21. Arizona Diamondbacks (Chris Garagiola, Tom Candiotti, Mike Ferrin, Josh Collmenter, Brandon Webb, Cole Tucker): 2.10
Most common grade: C (40.1% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 75.9%
2025 Ranking: 28th
The Diamondbacks’ radio broadcast saw a nice move up the rankings this year. Play-by-play voice Chris Garagiola earns high marks for stepping into the lead chair following the retirement of the iconic Greg Schulte. Fans love Garagiola’s “genuine” local connection, noting “his passion is clear and it makes me excited to listen every day.” Color commentators Tom Candiotti and Josh Collmenter supply “valuable pitcher insights,” while Mike Ferrin offers “quality” backup play-by-play. On the negative side, skeptical respondents argue Garagiola “doesn’t really have a feel for radio” yet, suggesting his “visual style” is better suited for television. Nevertheless, local supporters feel the young crew’s “energy level is perfect.”
“Chris Garagiola has to be one of the most underrated MLB play-by-play guys, and it’s probably because the D-backs don’t have the national reach that other teams do,” said one grader. “Regardless, he’s extremely sharp with his call, has great energy/excitement, and knows how to have a conversation with the audience.”
The greatest debut in baseball history.
Here’s how it sounded on your voice of the #stlcards! pic.twitter.com/ovQbcPPCzv
— KMOX Sports (@KMOXSports) August 15, 2026
20. St. Louis Cardinals (John Rooney, Ricky Horton, Mike Claiborne, Matt Pauley): 2.12
Most common grade: C (33.1% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 73.7%
2025 Ranking: 18th
Veteran broadcaster John Rooney leads a broadcast characterized by strong professional experience and “traditional Midwestern polish.” Supporters highlight Rooney’s knack for “combining serious plays with a little humor so seamlessly,” backed by analyst Ricky Horton. However, the booth receives significant pushback from some for leaning into “hyper-homerism” and frequently “trashing the opposing team and umpires.” Others express annoyance over repetitive sponsor placements and side topics during slow innings. Ultimately, while fans acknowledge the crew is “super knowledgeable,” the heavy home-team bias seems to hold down the grade.
“John Rooney is willing to call the team out when needed and has given us fans something to cheer for the last couple of years with his snark,” said one fan.
Shohei Ohtani’s game tying homerun and Mookie Bett’s walk off homer as called by Tim Neverett and Rick Monday. Electric call and an electric ending.
©SportsNetLA, AM570 LA Sports pic.twitter.com/VpmQzoW5cR— James¹⁷¹⁸
(@ShotimeLAD) September 23, 2024
19. Los Angeles Dodgers (Charley Steiner, Rick Monday, Tim Neverett, Stephen Nelson, José Mota): 2.21
Most common grade: C (30.7% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 68.8%
2025 Ranking: 12th
The Dodgers’ radio broadcast saw a significant drop this season, though given the sizable number of F grades and negative comments, we have a feeling some of that is runoff from how people feel about the franchise’s general reputation at the moment. Longtime voice Charley Steiner continues to return in a limited way, and his presence is “always welcome” and “a great story.” For the most part, the Dodgers’ multi-person booth is anchored by Stephen Nelson and Tim Neverett, both of whom draw praise for their “good fundamental” play-by-play mechanics and “great storytelling ability.” Former player Rick Monday brings “veteran authority” to his analysis. On the flip side, critical voters feel Neverett can be “too opinionated” and argue that Nelson’s delivery feels “a bit engineered” for television rather than radio. The constant rotation of announcers also leaves some listeners wishing for “more consistency.” Still, defenders view it as a “very good crew from top to bottom.”
“It’s great Charley is back even in a limited capacity,” said one grader.
Dave Sims and Suzyn Waldman call George Lombard Jr.’s first career home run
@davesims_pic.twitter.com/DLJ5xZnv3H
— WFAN Sports Radio (@WFAN660) August 5, 2026
18. New York Yankees (Dave Sims, Suzyn Waldman, Emmanuel Berbari): 2.24
Most common grade: B (26.7% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 72.3%
2025 Ranking: 16th
The first broadcast in the rankings that had a B as its most common grade, the scores were very mixed overall for the Yankees. Veteran announcer Dave Sims brings plenty of “requisite enthusiasm” and energy to the microphone, taking over the role from John Sterling. Longtime analyst Suzyn Waldman remains a polarizing but respected figure, with loyal fans insisting she is “one of a kind” and “long overdue for the Hall of Fame.” However, critics argue Sims can be “lackadaisical in painting the word picture” and occasionally struggles with radio game flow compared to TV. Young contributor Emmanuel Berbari receives positive mentions as a “fantastic” talent with a “bright future.” Overall, while some dismiss the crew as “overrated” or “not interested in how baseball is looked at in 2026,” supporters maintain that “Dave and Suzyn are a fun listen.”
“Homers, but well-informed homers,” added one grader.
Rays broadcasters Andy Freed and Doug Waechter turned the top of the fourth inning of Friday’s game into a Vanilla Ice career retrospective.
It starts the only way it can with “Stop, collaborate and listen.” pic.twitter.com/CSn3SjEiAH
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) August 19, 2023
17. Tampa Bay Rays (Andy Freed, Neil Solondz, Chris Adams-Wall, Doug Waechter): 2.26
Most common grade: C (38.2% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 79%
2025 Ranking: 20th
According to our graders, Andy Freed and Neil Solondz lead an “excellent, no-frills broadcast” that earns consistent praise for keeping listeners “informed and engaged.” Solondz is singled out as an absolute fan favorite, with graders calling him “incredible” and “the man, the myth, the legend.” The radio broadcast garnered praise for the way it “educates, entertains, and informs.” Minor critiques targeted guest analysts like Doug Waechter for “trying too hard to be funny,” but the core play-by-play duo receives top marks.
As one grader summarized: “They make me feel like family.”
The winning World Series clinching call for Eric Nadel and the @rangers. pic.twitter.com/D5UF3nNo7D
— Joe Wright (@Sctvman) November 2, 2023
16. Texas Rangers (Eric Nadel, Matt Hicks, Jared Sandler, Ted Emrich, Zach Bigley): 2.27
Most common grade: C (41.1% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 79.3%
2025 Ranking: 22nd
Broadcasters Eric Nadel and Matt Hicks continue to “delight” fans with their classic calls and “incredible connection to baseball and place.” Meanwhile, rising star Jared Sandler draws rave reviews as “a legend-in-the-making” who brings “infectious energy,” “deep statistical knowledge,” and “fun” to every broadcast. Listeners describe the Nadel-Sandler pairing as “absolute gold,” praising the booth for making complex game situations easy to follow. While a handful of voters dismiss the broadcast as “a bit boring” or “getting old,” the majority consider it “top-notch.” Fans summarize the trio as “one of the best in baseball”
“Eric Nadel, Matt Hicks, Jared Sandler, Ted Emrich, and Zach Bigley are an incredible broadcast team—knowledgeable, entertaining, authentic, and true professionals,” added one grader.
“There is no one in that dugout that deserved it more… that the fans, that the players wanted it more for than Joey Ortiz”
Lane Grindle nailed the whole sequence https://t.co/ZuOWJN9mZKpic.twitter.com/lXXDxzUGMd
— Tony Clements (@TonyCMKE) June 30, 2026
15. Milwaukee Brewers (Lane Grindle, Jeff Levering, Josh Maurer, Lane Grindle, Bill Schroeder, Tim Dillard): 2.31
Most common grade: C (30.8% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 78.3%
2025 Ranking: 10th
A year after saying goodbye to legendary broadcaster Bob Uecker, graders seem to feel that the Brewers’ radio broadcast is delivering a solid product, though not without concerns. Lead voices Jeff Levering and Lane Grindle receive decent marks, with fans calling Levering “a gem” and Grindle “one of the most underrated radio guys in the game.” Analysts Bill Schroeder and Tim Dillard inject “welcome personality,” though some listeners complain that Levering and Grindle “sound so similar it’s hard to tell them apart.” Fan frustrations stem from the perception that ownership enforces excessive sponsor reads. Nonetheless, locals appreciate the booth’s friendly “SW Wisconsin” tone, which keeps games accessible and pleasant.
“Great chemistry and no one tries to fill the shoes of the great one, Uecker,” said one fan. “Love the Midwest humbleness and the down-home broadcasts.”
Charlie Slowes in the booth
CJ Abrams in the rain
#NATITUDE // @budweiserusapic.twitter.com/cKxUHfDiuX
— Washington Nationals (@Nationals) June 22, 2023
14. Washington Nationals (Charlie Slowes, Dave Jageler, Josh Whetzel): 2.32
Most common grade: C (31.3% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 75.3%
2025 Ranking: 17th
The long-running partnership of Charlie Slowes and Dave Jageler remains a “cherished constant” for Nationals fans. Having called games together for nearly two decades, they have a “natural chemistry” and signature “Bang! Zoom!” calls that prompt many supporters to “mute the TV and sync to their feed.” Jageler is lauded for “painting pictures” with his words, while fill-in announcer Josh Whetzel earns high marks as a “treat” whenever he steps in. While critics argue the duo can occasionally sound “overly homerish,” many graders view them as “synonymous with Nationals baseball” and one of the most “reliable” duos in the league.
“Charlie and Dave are clearly having fun, as are their listeners, and no one outdoes their chemistry,” said one grader. “Their calls in big moments are magnificent.”
Eduardo Valencia hits his 5th home run of the year. Dan Dickerson on the call #DNMWpic.twitter.com/QD7DWQBEj2
— Dan Dickerson Calls
(@dannydHRs) August 13, 2026
13. Detroit Tigers (Dan Dickerson, Bobby Scales, Greg Gania, Dan Petry): 2.33
Most common grade: C (39.3% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 81.9%
2025 Ranking: 8th
Dan Dickerson remains the undisputed star of the Tigers’ broadcast, celebrated as “a true pro’s pro” with “no better home run call in the market.” Backed by “solid” play-by-play partner Greg Gania and former player analysts like Bobby Scales and Dan Petry, the booth maintains a “high standard.” Several respondents voiced frustration over Dickerson working so many television broadcasts, arguing it “disrupts his radio rhythm” and leads to occasional “stat overload.” Others note the commentary can occasionally feel “a bit dull” during non-competitive games. Still, the consensus holds that “Dickerson is an absolute gem” who keeps Tigers radio in good hands.
“These guys are knowledgeable and yet describe the action in a very approachable way,” said one grader. “I never feel like I need to strain past some weird flaw or gimmick to listen to them. They make listening to Tigers games easier.”
“Chadwick Tromp hitting ’em where it hurts… as one of the most unlikely heroes on the roster laced the game winning hit right up the middle!” – @IngramRadio | @BravesRadioNethttps://t.co/DzLyIMfs1Spic.twitter.com/brAoHGlqYi
— 680 The Fan (@680TheFan) May 23, 2026
12. Atlanta Braves (Ben Ingram, Joe Simpson, Tom Hart, Darren O’Day): 2.35
Most common grade: C (35.4% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 81.8%
2025 Ranking: 14th
Ben Ingram anchors the Braves’ radio feed, earning near-universal acclaim as “incredible” and the primary reason “that puts this team near the top.” Listeners love the overall “old-school feel of this booth”, noting Ingram’s rich voice feels like a “good listen driving around in the South” and one that “throws me back to the golden age of radio.” Former reliever Darren O’Day garnered praise for “really coming around to being a good color guy,” complementing veteran Joe Simpson’s “traditional” perspective. A few detractors complained about Ingram’s fondness for “kitchy phrases” like “stick” or “hurler,” but most regard him as a “top-tier play-by-play caller.”
As one fan put it, there’s “no better fit for this team than Ingram.”
wow
How the most important home run in Blue Jays history sounded on Blue Jays radio pic.twitter.com/Q0sguknOO0
— Nick Piccone (@_piccone) October 21, 2025
11. Toronto Blue Jays (Ben Shulman, Chris Leroux, Eric Smith, Ben Nicholson-Smith, Blake Murphy): 2.39
Most common grade: B (37.5% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 82.1%
2025 Ranking: 13th
Young play-by-play talent Ben Shulman earns frequent praise for sounding “as professional as his dad” (national broadcaster Dan Shulman). Paired with analyst Chris Leroux, graders feel the booth achieves a “lighthearted” dynamic that strikes “a good combination of analysis and fun.” While cynical graders occasionally grumble about “nepotism” or suggest that “inexperience shows” during tight late-game moments, many other fans appreciate Shulman’s rapid growth and “polished cadence.” The team avoids being “full-on homers” while maintaining a distinct regional charm.
“So Canadian and I love it,” said one grader.
Two Schwarbombs in one inning
Two incredible Scott Franzke calls pic.twitter.com/Yq8SGK4jf7— Nick Piccone (@_piccone) June 21, 2026
10. Philadelphia Phillies (Scott Franzke, Kevin Stocker, Gregg Murphy, Larry Andersen): 2.54
Most common grade: C (29.8% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 84.5%
2025 Ranking: 6th
The Phillies broadcast takes a slight step back from last year’s rankings, but not for a lack of appreciation. Many graders viewed play-by-play voice Scott Franzke as a “genuine Philadelphia treasure” and “the best in the business.” His banter with longtime color analyst Larry Andersen (“LA”) received multiple comparisons to the legendary Phillies duo of Harry Kalas and Richie Ashburn. Together, they deliver “the perfect blend of calling the game, humor, being critical when deserved, and calling big moments.” While Andersen’s occasional grumpiness or “ump baiting” wasn’t for everyone, analysts Kevin Stocker and Gregg Murphy provide excellent, polished support.
“Franzke is tremendous,” added one grader. “It truly doesn’t get any better than this.”
what a call by Len Kasper pic.twitter.com/fxAJzWoi6y
— Zach (ザック) (@zachsox) May 17, 2026
9. Chicago White Sox (Len Kasper, Darrin Jackson, Connor McKnight): 2.55
Most common grade: B (29.9% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 82.8%
2025 Ranking: 9th
Despite several rough seasons on the field, the White Sox radio booth remains a “major bright spot” for South Side fans. Broadcaster Len Kasper is widely praised for his ability to “elevate any analyst” and paint an “accurate and vivid” view that makes the radio call “vastly superior to the TV call” to some. Some North Side transplants in the comments still lament the loss of Kasper, noting that he is “in his element” on the radio. Former White Sox outfielder Darrin “DJ” Jackson brings a “comfortable” presence to color commentary, while fill-in voice Connor McKnight is singled out as a “truly pleasant surprise.” Graders ultimately seemed to agree that this is a “delightful broadcast” that “makes bad games enjoyable.”
“Both Len Kasper and Connor McKnight are very good,” added one fan. “Would love to hear Connor do even more.”
“SWUNG ON AND DRIVEN HIGH. AND DEEP. AND GONE. WALK-OFF HOMER. CEDDANNE. SAY GOODNIGHT. HE CANNOT BE STOPPED.”
Will Flemming calls the dramatic homer on WEEI.pic.twitter.com/QR2NpAT3Behttps://t.co/8AysV44aW9
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) July 12, 2025
8. Boston Red Sox (Will Flemming, Will Middlebrooks, Sean McDonough, Cooper Boardman, Lenny DiNardo, Mike Monaco, Rob Bradford): 2.59
Most common grade: B (36.5% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 82.6%
2025 Ranking: 7th
Boasting “some of the best personality of any booth in the league,” the Red Sox radio broadcast still garners divided opinion but strong overall scores. Lead broadcaster Will Flemming is hailed by supporters as “severely underrated” and a true pro who forms “a great duo with great chemistry” alongside analyst Will Middlebrooks (Jazz Chisholm might disagree). Guest appearances by Sean McDonough are “a special treat,” adding “effortlessly funny” banter to the mix. Critics argue Flemming can be “a bit generic” or “overly dramatic on routine plays.” Still, with strong fill-ins like Mike Monaco and Lenny DiNardo, most graders seemed to agree it was an “easily hands down best listen” candidate.
“They all have a contemporary sense of humor that only adds to the broadcasts,” said one grader. “Any booth that can claim Sean McDonough for 20 or so games should get an automatic A.”
Wake up to Rick Rizzs Walk Off call last night
pic.twitter.com/ByxO6WS0EE
— Trident True (@TridentTrue) June 11, 2024
7. Seattle Mariners (Rick Rizzs, Gary Hill, Ryan Rowland-Smith, Shannon Drayer): 2.62
Most common grade: A (29.6% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 85.5%
2025 Ranking: 11th
The first team to receive a most common grade of A in our rankings this year, the Mariners’ broadcast has a lot of Rizzs (sorry). Pacific Northwest listeners are rallying around departing legend Rick Rizzs, calling him a true “Seattle institution” and “a treasure” who deserves a proper send-off. While Rizzs’ classic voice evokes “deep nostalgia,” some graders note he has “lost a step” and that the booth relies heavily on its rotating cast. Partner Gary Hill offers “dependable” and “strong” work, while analysts Ryan Rowland-Smith (“Hyphen”) and Shannon Drayer bring “accessible” local perspectives. Some graders expressed significant apprehension about the future, warning that the team “desperately needs to nail Rizzs’ successor” to maintain the level of quality they’re used to.
“Rick Rizzs will be missed big time,” said one fan. “He belongs in Cooperstown. Enjoy your retirement, Rick; you have earned it. I have enjoyed every broadcast you have ever done. A+ career; you should be very proud.”
COLTON COWSER SAVES THE DAY!
Cowser robs a Home Run from Colorado’s Jake McCarthy to secure the O’s win in the first game against the Rockies with a final score of 2-1. @BrettHollander has the call of the amazing catch by Cowser! pic.twitter.com/MBYCReNEWY
— WBAL NewsRadio 1090 and FM 101.5 (@wbalradio) September 1, 2026
6. Baltimore Orioles (Brett Hollander, Josh Lewin, Ben Wagner, Ben McDonald): 2.74
Most common grade: A (34.8% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 86.5%
2025 Ranking: 21st
Making the biggest jump in this year’s rankings, the Orioles’ radio broadcast flew 15 spots higher and almost cracked the Top 5. What changed? The Orioles’ radio booth stood out to our graders due to its “high-energy dynamic” and “deep roster of talent.” Lead voice Brett Hollander received glowing reviews, with fans calling him “the absolute best” and praising the “jolt of enthusiasm” he brings to the call. Former player Ben McDonald is celebrated as a “breakout star” who matches big moments with “poetic word choices,” while veteran Josh Lewin is considered a “pro’s pro.” Although a few graders feel Hollander can occasionally sound “too loud,” the overall consensus is positive.
“Brett Hollander is the most genuine, exciting, and articulate broadcaster we’ve had in a VERY long time,” said one grader. “The fact that he grew up in Baltimore, as a die-hard Orioles fan, makes him authentic.”
Howie Rose did it again, too. pic.twitter.com/F9SadusBGA
— Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) October 6, 2024
5. New York Mets (Howie Rose, Keith Raad, Pat McCarthy): 2.79
Most common grade: A (41% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 83.2%
2025 Ranking: 5th
As legendary play-by-play announcer Howie Rose prepares for retirement, graders showered him with praise as “still the best in the business” and “close to irreplaceable.” As one person put it, there is “no one in MLB today is better at weaving in stories and anecdotes while also properly describing the game.” Younger booth partners Keith Raad and Pat McCarthy earn strong marks for their “fresh energy,” with a sense they are “set up to run with Mets broadcasts for the next two decades.” A vocal contingent of loyal fans expresses anxiety over the upcoming transition, worrying whether Raad is fully “ready to step into [Rose’s] shoes.” Nevertheless, the overall sentiment remains one of gratitude for a booth that has consistently delivered “A-tier” broadcasting.
“Howie is an icon who will forever be intertwined with team lore as much as Mets players themselves,” said one fan.
Jo Adell blasted a 3-run 455-foot home run and Tom Hamilton goes absolutely berserk #GuardsBallpic.twitter.com/1xrj5bI2aW
— Roberto Shenanigans (@Rob_Shenanigans) August 18, 2026
4. Cleveland Guardians (Tom Hamilton, Jim Rosenhaus, Ryan Mitchell, Tim Belcher, Charles Nagy, Pat Tabler): 2.82
Most common grade: A (41% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 83.3%
2025 Ranking: 4th
Cleveland’s booth is defined by Hall of Fame broadcaster Tom Hamilton, whom graders overwhelmingly crowned “the absolute gold standard of what a local radio broadcast should be.” Even rival supporters in the comments conceded that Hamilton is “certainly on the Mount Rushmore” of sports announcers, bringing “unrivaled electricity to big moments.” Fans appreciate that “he doesn’t get all melancholy for the opposing team” and “will often get properly excited for the opponent when they do something spectacular.” Steady partner Jim Rosenhaus provides a “balanced” and “reliable” counterpart to Hamilton’s “high-octane” calls.
As one fan put it, “The Guards can be unwatchable at times, but they are almost never unlistenable because of how good Hammy is on the mic.”
Pete Crow-Armstrong just makes things happen.
Pat Hughes’ call of Pete’s game-winning steal+advance with a nifty prediction from Ron Coomer:
(@thescorechicago) pic.twitter.com/0CPZNOdOhX
— Patrick Norton (@patdnorton) August 6, 2026
3. Chicago Cubs (Pat Hughes, Ron Coomer, Zach Zaidman): 2.85
Most common grade: A (40.7% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 87%
2025 Ranking: 3rd
Iconic radio voice Pat Hughes continues to be celebrated as “a national treasure” and “an all-time legend” who “sets the bar” for baseball broadcasting. Graders dubbed his long-standing partnership with color analyst Ron Coomer “the goods,” with many loving “their connection” and “hear[ing] them laughing in the booth” during summer afternoons. Coomer’s relatable style “makes you feel like you’re sitting at the bar with a buddy watching the game,” balancing entertainment with “sharp game analysis.” While middle-inning play-by-play contributor Zach Zaidman draws mixed reviews for being a bit “unreliable” on game action, he is acknowledged as “getting better as a regular fill-in.” Ultimately, most graders agreed that “Pat and Ron are the gold standard.”
“Hard to believe the Cubs would be able to replicate the on-air broadcast after Ron Santo passed away, but they did with an A+,” said one fan.
“IT’S A GRAND SLAM! I CAN’T BELIEVE IT!!!”
Jon Miller narrated the moment of the year. Here’s what it sounded like on THE Sports Leader.
pic.twitter.com/7sRxzbppUO
— KNBR (@KNBR) June 10, 2026
2. San Francisco Giants (Jon Miller, Dave Flemming, Duane Kuiper, Joe Ritzo, Glen Kuiper, Mike Krukow, Hunter Pence, Joe Ritzo, F. P. Santangelo): 3.269
Most common grade: A (62.5% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 89.7%
2025 Ranking: 1st
The defending champs from last year’s rankings fell just short of repeating this year, though their numbers are nothing to be ashamed of. With over 60% of graders giving them an A and almost 90% giving them an A/B/C grade, the Giants booth remains a huge winner in listeners’ ears as “the gold standard” and “the GOATs.” Hall of Famer Jon Miller remains an “absolute national treasure,” with fans noting that he “still has his fastball” as he “weaves classic storytelling” across the airwaves. Partner Dave Flemming is “pretty hard to beat in many regards,” providing the perfect bridge as Miller represents the “old guard” and Flemming the “new guard.” Additional contributions from TV figures Mike Krukow and Duane Kuiper make the rotation feel like an “absolute embarrassment of riches.”
“Best booth in the league,” said one fan. “Giants fans are blessed.”
“The ultimate answer.” — @tonygwynnjr
Here’s how Jurickson Profar’s grand slam sounded on the Padres Radio Network with @jesseagler on the call. pic.twitter.com/RufGhqPTi4
— 97.3 The Fan (@973TheFanSD) June 26, 2024
1. San Diego Padres (Jesse Agler, Tony Gwynn Jr., Sam Levitt, Bob Scanlan): 3.274
Most common grade: A (64.1% of votes)
Percentage of A/B/C grades: 89.8%
2025 Ranking: 2nd
The vote between the Giants and Padres was so close that we had to round the final grades to three decimal places, but in the end, the Padres can now claim to have both MLB’s top TV and radio broadcasts, according to Awful Announcing readers. San Diego’s broadcast team was hailed by graders as “just awesome” and “the best of the best.” Lead play-by-play voice Jesse Agler earns near-universal praise as “one of the smartest PBP guys in baseball,” whose “prep really shines through as top quality.” Alongside former major leaguer Tony Gwynn Jr. and veteran analyst Bob Scanlan, Agler delivers a call packed with “in-depth statistics” and is appreciated for his “legendary” “GONNA GOOO!” home run call. Respondents also give special credit to longtime producer/engineer Dave Marcus, pointing out that “more than 30 years of helping shape one of the best radio broadcasts” creates “unmatched booth chemistry.”
“The team of Jesse, Tony, Bob, and Sam is the absolute best!” raved one grader. “Very informed broadcast crew that paints a vibrant picture for the listener.”
The post Awful Announcing’s 2026 MLB local radio broadcaster rankings appeared first on Awful Announcing.